Productive Debate: Practically Defined, Real Life Example & Checklist

  1. Share
0 0

Think of an argument that you’ve been in.

One where you and the other person were on opposite ends of the topic you both care deeply about.

The outcome of this discussion has real consequences, and so passion is evident.

You each believe fully in your stance.

Back and forth it goes, and neither of you is willing to concede.

Now, imagine ten people who know you watched this dialogue unfold.

What would those watching be feeling?

What would they hear?

What would they see?

How would their view of you and the other person change?


It’s possible to demonstrate leadership excellence while not getting your way.

It’s possible to engage in an energized disagreement and have people respect you more after the fact.


I’ve experienced it; it’s awesome. I want to be that kind of leader, and I want you to be that kind of leader.


So how the heck is this possible?!


Productive Debate Defined

At CCB Technology, our Executive team has been working with an EOS implementor for about a year now.

It’s been a lot. Good, but a lot.

In one of our sessions, we discussed Healthy Conflict, specifically how the term “healthy conflict” has a weird connotation.


In the next session, our EOS implementor read off a term—Productive Debate.


Defining each of the terms will help us know why this phrase is a good one.


Productive: Yielding good, useful or expected results

Debate: A (formal) discussion on a particular matter where opposing arguments are put forward


A Productive Debate is a discussion on a particular matter where opposing arguments are put forward, yielding good, useful results.

While the term may be made up, the above definition is something we should all shoot for when a disagreement happens.


Real Life Example

The introductory hypothetical scenario of 10 people watching you in a heated dialogue was taken from a real situation I was in.


Not too long ago, I was in the room with about a dozen guys I hold in high regard. Like, trust with my kids/life savings kind of high regard. Our meeting was partly to help make decisions.


One topic that needed a vote was presented. Two of the guys at the table had opposing arguments. Each was logical in its rationale and convincing. And neither was willing to surrender their position.


As the conversation continued, I started taking notes. It was the best example I have seen of our earlier term, the Productive Debate. When all was said and done, a vote was cast, and the group determined which was the better of the ideas.


When I left, my respect for this group of men was at an all-time high. This was done in such a healthy way that those in the room benefited from their demonstration of leadership maturity.


Later in the week, I referenced my notes to try and simplify how this was possible. The rest are some of my findings.


The Building Blocks of Productive Debate

  • Show up mature, be a person of substance
    • Your responses show the self-work done before the debate takes place (or lack of work done)
    • Everything the guys in the above example said was directed at the topic


  • Stick to your points
    • This is about what’s best for the organization, not you
    • Zero personal attacks; ideas are up for debate, not the person across from you


  • Pause. Listen.
    • These guys didn’t interrupt each other-not even once in 20+ minutes
    • Interrupting takes the focus from the topic to etiquette & respect


  • Ask clarifying questions
    • What would you say is best for _____ then?
    • If it’s _____, why did we do _____ in the past?
    • Is there something you could name that would add value to _____ if we did what you suggested?


  • Maintain tone, volume, posture & composure
    • The guys didn’t raise their voices, even when a great counterpoint was made.
    • If their heart rates were escalated, I couldn’t tell.


There is a way to lose an argument that also demonstrates leadership excellence.

There is a way to win an argument and lose your credibility.


You’re a leader. When you fail, apologize. When you find yourself in a debate, breathe. People are watching you.

Work on your inner life, stick to your points, pause & listen, ask questions, and maintain composure.


Need more? 

Check out the IOL Community Groups to connect with like-minded leaders!

Go to our YouTube and LinkedIn pages for more encouraging content.  

We’ve got over 100 podcasts to aid in your growth as a leader!


To leave a comment, login or sign up.

Related Content

Comfort Kills Growth: Preparing Mentally For Healthy Conflict (script included)
People might say they don’t mind change, but they do.  Most of us mind it a lot.    We like being comfortable, but comfort doesn’t lead to growth.    As you take steps toward introducing healthy conflict in your home or at work, here are 4 things to be mentally prepared for.    Awkwardness  As a leader, you are introducing a new concept.  Remember that most everyone else won’t have a reference point in their minds for it.  Extending grace and kindness are invaluable as people react to this new thing.  Many responses that outwardly look like resistance come from the discomfort of our brains needing to be rewired.  Seriously. Our nervous system consists of neurons (nerve cells) that transmit nerve signals or messages to and from the brain.  According to Psychology Today, “Neuroplasticity underlies the capacity for learning and memory, and it enables mental and behavioral flexibility. Research has firmly established that the brain is a dynamic organ and can change its design throughout life, responding to experience by reorganizing connections—via so-called “wiring” and “rewiring.” Scientists sometimes refer to the process of neuroplasticity as structural remodeling of the brain.”  The good news is that you can retrain or rewire your brain.  The bad news is that it takes work. When you bring healthy conflict to your spouse, friends, or coworkers, remember that you’ve been exercising and training your brain to recognize the discomfort as just being part of the process.  But no one else’s brain knows that.  Their neurons are carrying semi truckloads of information telling them there’s confusion, danger, uncertainty, and discomfort down this road.  This is why it gets awkward.  Most people just can’t help but feel weird about it.  Try not to take it personally.  The awkwardness is worth it.  I promise.   Disappointment  I remember when my boss, Patrick, and I really got serious about pursuing healthy conflict.  We both were excited about what Pat Lencioni had written in his book The Five Dysfunctions of a Team, and we were ready to build a stronger team.  The problem was that we found ourselves fighting old patterns of thought more than anything else.  It was disappointing.  It was also part of the process.  It takes 60 days (or more) of practice to really get into a habit of having healthy conflict as part of your routine.   As I found out, you can mess up a lot of conversations in 60 days if you’re not careful.    Patience is a virtue in this process. We’ve found that disappointment comes in several forms.  Negative self-talk can easily happen, especially when group participation is taking longer than expected.  Beware of thoughts like, “I’m alone in this” popping up.  Frustration can also build in other ways. Perhaps a positional leader in your company just won’t lean into the process.  There is also the disappointment that comes when everyone else in the room is having a Tony Robbins-type breakthrough and you aren’t.  People are people.  You can’t control what they do or how they feel.  Listen to them, empathize, reinforce the ‘why’, and keep stepping forward.    Assumptions Good or bad, the experiences from our past shape our worldview.  These assumptions will inevitably be tagging along with everyone in the room.  Including you. Whether it’s “here we go again”, “I’m just not the type that opens up”, “this is exactly what we need” or 100 others—assumptions will be present. Knowing assumptions are present is critical.  Calling them out to the group at the beginning is where the power lies. You don’t have to be controlled by your preconceived notions.  However, many will feel stuck, even if they don’t articulate it.  Their outward resistance is a symptom of the inward battle.  “I’ve seen this before; it doesn’t end well for me” is a common reaction from people who have been burned by showing vulnerability.  “I’m just not wired that way” is what you’ll often hear from strong personalities.  “I’ve done fine without it so far” is what most smart, successful people think to themselves.  There’s another option.  None of us are stuck.  Even when it feels that way.  In section 6 of our eBook, you’ll find a scrip.  Take this script and make it your own. It will help bring everyone to a common starting position.  Assumptions and all. As gently as I can put it: No one gets to opt-out of this.  Your prior experiences, personality, and success are all real.  None of that gives you a pass on healthy conflict though.   Surprises Guaranteed, you will be surprised in the process of adopting healthy conflict into your leadership.  Right when you think someone will never, ever take a posture of humility--they apologize and speak directly about their misstep.  The other side to that coin are the territorial responses from seemingly non-territorial people.  As my pastor Mike Bullmore says; “People are like cups.  If they get bumped hard enough, you’ll see what’s inside.” Those surprisingly territorial people probably haven’t been bumped in a while.  And you just bumped them big time.    When it happens, encourage the person to stay there.  Label what you’re seeing.  Such as: “it seems like you’re feeling ___”, and let them correct or agree with you.  Ask open-ended questions to draw the person out:  “Tell me about…,” “Help me understand…,”.  Or encouraging statements like: “I’m with you.  Keep going with that last thing you said.”   Balance, awareness, and finesse are required here.  Not perfection.  Think interview vs. interrogation. Reassure them that this is what healthy conflict looks like and is exactly why you all are doing this.  You’re identifying areas of conflict and staring them in the face with the hope of enjoying the health on the other side of these conversations.      You will also be surprised at your own growth along the way.  The ability to sit in the awkwardness becomes more your style as your brain gets rewired by the repetitions day after day.   We've got your back! Get the eBook for $Free.99 Check out our YouTube and LinkedIn pages for more encouraging content.   If you’re looking to take your growth as a leader to the next level, we’ve got you covered. Join the Impact of Leadership Community today